Why Vodafone’s New Postpaid plans are better than Airtel My plan : Our Analysis

Vodafone IN has launched 5 postpaid plans for Karnataka Circle starting this December 2013 for new and existing customers. These 5 postpaid plans are in price segments of 199(/sec & /min), 299 and 399(/sec & /min) respectively and also come with good monthly benefits. My opinion immediately after analyzing these plans is “These Plans are really created with an intention that a general customer should opt for without a second thought to choose from per sec and per minute plans at affordable prices.”

The details of all the 5 plans launched are as below:

Vodafone Karnataka Plans

After observing the price tags 199,299 and 399 of Vodafone, this clearly shows that these plans are launched with an intention to give tough competition to Airtel’s My Plan 199,299 and 299. Now, let us analyze what really these two operators are providing to their customers.

airtel-myplan-vodafone plans

If we observe all the plans and benefits we can conclude:

Pulse: Vodafone is providing per/sec and per/min tariff whereas Airtel’s MyPlan is only having per/min tariff in all the plans. Also Vodafone reduced base rates of calls to 30p, 40p and 50p in some plans.

SMS: Though Vodafone plans lack the flexibility to choose your own sms packs it is giving default sms (Local/STD) for 50paise in all the plans while 199 and 399 plans have free sms benefit included too whereas Airtel is charging base rates as indicated in the table.

Actual Free Monthly Benefits: If we clearly observe Vodafone Monthly freebies all Local or STD seconds/Minutes can be used for all Local or STD calls (Mobile/landline) but Airtel’s MyPlan Freebies can be used only with Mobiles as the freebies clearly state Local Mobile Minutes or STD Mobile Minutes which is a drawback.

Roaming: Roaming tariff is same in both Vodafone’s and Airtel’s plans.


myplan benefit

Conclusion: Vodafone IN plans are value plans a customer can afford whereas Airtel MyPlan plans are completely flexible packages created by you just for you. After all it’s the amount of Calls/SMS or Data used by a user that will give the right value for the money spent. So, in my opinion if you ask me I’ll opt for VF 199 per second plan in lower segment or VF 399 per second plan in higher segment as no plan in Airtel’s myplan even if it is made by me for me is completely satisfying any particular usage pattern because if we observe we are truly getting less value or distributed benefits which do not completely benefit us in any way. I made a best possible attempt to make it very clear which are the best plans to opt for in the form of comparisons and after all in the end everything is based on personal opinion and usage patterns.

If you are a user who is planning to switch to any of these two operators just for good postpay plans  i will say “If you want your conversations to be flexible go for Vodafone Plans, if you want your plan to be flexible go for Airtel Myplan.”

Let me and other users know via comments which plan will you choose from in case if you go for one ?

Passionately following the Indian #Telecom Industry for over a decade from Business, Consumer and a Technical perspective. My primary focus area is Consumer & Digital Experience.

Leave a Reply

Photo and Image Files
41 Comment threads
28 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
53 Comment authors
Lakhwinder Singhwinod raiJaydeep KumarBharatSandeep Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Lakhwinder Singh
Lakhwinder Singh

Airtel is best . because it’s top in india in Telecom industry and 1st Telecom which provide large rage coverage anywhere.

winod rai
winod rai

Telecomtalk is a great site. There’s one fatal flaw though.
The date of the article is given at the bottom. Besides, old articles are pushed in the periphery of new ones. There’s NO way to find out when you land if the article if old or new (unless you scroll down of course).

Kind of stupid IMO

Recent Posts

Bharti Airtel Adds Rs 2 Lakh Life Insurance to Rs 149 Plan and Makes it Rs 179

Bharti Airtel has launched a new affordable prepaid plan of Rs 179 across all the 22 telecom circles. The Rs...

Trai New Multi TV Policy Reduces Attractiveness of D2h and Dish TV Connections

Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) has already laid out the new rules of the game for the DTH industry....

Tata Sky Binge+ Set-Top Box Offers Some Unique Services Like 7 Days Playback and Bundled OTT

The next step in the DTH industry and perhaps the second stage in the digitisation of the DTH services is...