Vodafone Idea and Bharti Airtel Might Have to Pay Higher License and Spectrum Fees

The telecom operators might get more financially burdened if the spectrum usage fees and the license fees are hiked because of the SC decision

Highlights
  • As per the Govt, the AGR should include revenue from non-core services as well
  • The telcos have said that the AGR should only include core telecom services

Indian telecom operators might have to shell out as much as Rs 41,000 crore in additional spectrum usage charges (SUC) if a matter falls in favour of the government regarding the definition of adjusted gross revenue (AGR) which is currently going on in Supreme Court. As per a new ET report, this figure will be asked from the telecom companies over the Rs 92,000 crore which has already been asked from the telcos in the name of penalties and license fees. The government is adamant on the fact that AGR constitutes the entire revenue of the company, whereas the telcos have resisted saying that the AGR only includes core services.

Bharti Airtel and Vodafone Idea to Take the Most Hit

Out of the total spectrum usage charges that the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) will ask from the telecom operators, 85% will be demanded from Vodafone Idea and Bharti Airtel. As per the estimates calculated by DoT, the Sunil Bharti Mittal led telco will pay somewhere around Rs 22,940 crore which would include interest and penalties. Whereas, the dues for Vodafone Idea have been pegged to be around Rs 11,000 crore. Even though the matter of spectrum usage charges does not factor into the argument which is ongoing in the Supreme Court, if the order on the definition of AGR comes in favour of the government, the DoT will have a strong basis to retrieve these dues from the telecom operators.

An official of DoT aware of the legal matters said about this new development, “We can proceed with spectrum usage charge demands once the AGR ruling comes in.” On the matter of deciding the proper definition of AGR, the Supreme Court had reserved its order. It is worth noting that spectrum usage charges and license fees are both calculated on the basis of AGR. As per the government, the AGR should include dividends, handset sales, rent and profit from the sale of scrap, whereas the telcos say that the AGR’s scope is limited to the revenue from telecom services alone.

Financial Burden for Telcos Might Increase

Currently, the spectrum usage charge is billed as 3% of the AGR. The current method of calculation of AGR includes some non-core elements as well. The DoT is bullish on receiving the pending dues which it will get if the order from SC falls in its favour. But, if that happens, then the already cash burdened telco Vodafone Idea will have another liability on its shoulder. Currently, the telecom operator is facing financially tough times after being bruised by the data tariff war.

In the FY19, the telecom sector’s AGR has decreased by 25% to Rs 1.39 lakh crore. This figure was previously Rs 1.85 lakh crore in FY17 as per the government data available. Rajan Matthews, Director General of COAI (Cellular Operators Association of India) said that the amounts could be very large and it is very worrisome for the telecom operators. The COAI represents all the telecom operators in the industry.

Arpit spends his day closely following the telecom and tech industry. A music connoisseur and a night owl, he also takes a deep interest in the Indian technology start-up scene and spends rest of his time spilling poetry and stories on paper.

16
Leave a Reply

avatar
Photo and Image Files
 
 
 
7 Comment threads
9 Thread replies
1 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
12 Comment authors
ShahnazVishal | ChennaiNikhilRaviKARTHIK Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
KARTHIK
KARTHIK

Instead of focusing only on postpaid Airtel and Vodafone Idea has to do some little ground work at least to make prepaid customers comfortable and ease with good(Here i am not telling better/best) Speed , Coverage and call quality(All three are worst in my place on both networks) and in terms of what they are paying for. Simply giving free data / *121# special offers will not retain their customers. They dig their own graveyard . Still their careless towards prepaid customers continues(Even after 3 years of JIO entry). Simple example . In terms of Bus fare for the same… Read more »

City
Mysore
Operator
JIO , Airtel
Shahnaz
Shahnaz

Exactly, so I moved to Airtel this time. Speed of Jio was always above 10 Mbps in my area, going upto 65 Mbps sometimes.

Screenshot_2019-09-12-17-54-11-805_com.microsoft.office.outlook.png
Chetan- Gurgaon
Chetan- Gurgaon

Friends please look around the world and understand that where ever three telcos are left, the third one is struggling because there is always an operator who spends a lot and provide omnipresence coverage and second one provides mixture both speeds and coverage and third one is unable to spend on network and remains third. So are we saying that regulators around the world are supporting number 1 telco descremently ?? Are regulators around the world corrupt and hand in gloves with number 1 telco. TRAI has always maintained that vil and Airtel situation is what they have created themselves… Read more »

Ravi
Ravi

Very aptly put as always. Singapore has M1 which is at verge of collapse, Australia has same issue. Even new Zealand has same situation… 3rd and 4th Telco around the world are merging to save their life….

Recent Posts

Reliance Jio Joins Other Telcos to Announce Tariff Hike In Coming Weeks

The biggest change that the telecom industry is going through right now seems to be on the tariff front. To...

Xiaomi Redmi Note 8 vs Mi A3: Which Budget Smartphone is Better

Xiaomi is the ultimate smartphone winner in the market right now when it comes to buying budget or mid-range smartphones....

Xiaomi Mi Band 4i Teased By Xiaomi, Likely to Come With Tapered Features and Lesser Price Tag

This year Xiaomi has made some very successful releases in India, and that does not only mean smartphones. The Chinese...