Mumbai 2G Drive test results 2015- Idea has the best 2G network, Reliance not so reliable

TRAI conducts Audit and Assessment  of Quality of Service being provided by the  service providers through independent  agencies for Cellular Mobile Telephone Services, Basic Services and Broadband  Services. As a part  of this audit, the Audit  Agency,  M/s TUV SUD has carried  out special  independent drive test for 2G Cellular Mobile Telephone Services of Bharti Airtel, Vodafone India, Idea Cellular, Reliance Communications, Aircel and Tata Docomo in Mumbai in  June July, 2015 and verified the findings with a second independent drive test conducted on the same routes in the city in September 2015.

Fullscreen capture 26-10-2015 101021.bmp

The report assess the network condition most specifically Radio Frequency coverage, the accessibility of the network (measured by the call setup success rate  and the block call rate), the retainability of the network (measured by drop call rate) and voice quality. Both the 900 MHz as well as 1800 MHz networks being used by all operators to provide 2G voice services were considered in the study. The details of the number of BTS set up by each operator in Mumbai circle and the number of users being served by each BTS is given in the table below. The more the number of users per BTS the more congested the network is considered.

Operator name Technology Band (MHz) BTS Count Subscribers* (Prepaid + Postpaid) Subscribers / BTS
Idea GSM 1800 3477 4010062 1153
Airtel GSM 900 & 1800 4025 4700857 1168
Vodafone GSM 900 & 1800 4543 8609116 1895
Reliance (GSM) GSM 1800 2178 2780944 1277
Aircel GSM 1800 1869 2536925 1357
Tata(GSM) GSM 1800 2887 2851020 988

Drive test route for Mumbai circle:

The drive test was conducted over a total route length of 300 kilometres in Mumbai circle passing through areas of Navi nagar, Colaba, Nariman point, Churchgate, Marine lines, Pedar road, Malabar Hill, Dadar, Khar, Andheri, Charkop, Malad, Dahisar, Mira-Bhayandar, Matunga, Sion, Ghatkopar, Sakinaka, Mankhurd, Govandi, Punam nagar, Nilam nagar, JVLR, etc. The drive test was carried out from 9AM to 8.30PM along these routes and a total of 2913 calls were made from all 6 networks. The performance was measured on 7 parameters which are enlisted below.

RF coverage rate:

RF Coverage relates to the geographical footprint within the system that has sufficient RF signal strength to provide for a call/data session. The Coverage rate of an operator is calculated basis of % of samples in which the Rx level is better than -85 dbm. The coverage rate varies from 95.00% (for Idea) to 87.30% (for Reliance GSM). The details are as follows.

Operator name Coverage Rate Ranking
Aircel 90.02% 4
Idea 95.00% 1
Vodafone 88.65% 5
Airtel 91.10% 3
Reliance (GSM) 87.30% 6
Tata(GSM) 94.92% 2

 

Accessibility:

Accessibility  is  the  ability  of  a  service  to  be  obtained within  specific  tolerances  and  other  given conditions, when requested by the user. In other words, the ability of a user to obtain the requested service from the system.  Accessibility is monitored by measuring Call Setup Success Rate (CSSR) which is defined as the ratio of Established Calls to Call Attempts. Call block is when a call is attempted but fails to be established. The benchmark is 95%. The performance of the operators varies from 95.82% (for Idea) to 85.51% (for Reliance GSM). The details are as follows.

Operator Name Total CallsAttempted Total Calls Blocked CSSR Ranking
Aircel 497 23 95.37% 4
Idea 502 11 97.81% 1
Vodafone 498 13 97.39% 2
Airtel 464 14 96.98% 3
Reliance (GSM) 497 37 92.56% 6
Tata (GSM) 455 22 95.16% 5

Retainability:

Retainability  is  “The  ability  of  a  service,  once  obtained,  to  continue  to  be  provided  under  given conditions for a requested duration.” For determining the retainability a parameter namely Call completion success rate (CCSR) is used which implies the percentage of established calls which continue till manually disconnected by the caller and are not cut off mid sentence due to loss of signal or congested BTS. The call drop and Connection with good voice quality were monitored by the drive test. The performance of TSPs varies from 97.36% (for Idea) to 94.49% (for Vodafone) as shown below.

Operator name Total CallsEstablished Total CallsDropped CCSR Ranking
Aircel 476 14 97.06% 3
Idea 492 13 97.36% 1
Vodafone 472 26 94.49% 6
Airtel 448 12 97.32% 2
Reliance (GSM) 463 15 96.76% 4
Tata (GSM) 439 24 94.53% 5


Mobility:

In a cellular system a base station has only a limited coverage area. Hence it is possible for a moving subscriber to get out of reach of a base station while making a call. The process by which a mobile telephone call is transferred from one base station to another as the subscriber passes the boundary of a cell is called a handover (HO). The Handover success rate (HOSR) more than 95% is considered to be good. The performance of the TSPs varies from 98.23 % (for Idea) to 94.95% (for Airtel) as shown below.

Operator name Total HO Attempt Total HO Success HOSR % Ranking
Aircel 897 872 97.21% 3
Idea 1358 1334 98.23% 1
Vodafone 1560 1517 97.24% 2
Airtel 1446 1373 94.95% 6
Reliance (GSM) 1248 1210 96.96% 5
Tata (GSM) 1360 1321 97.13% 4

Voice Quality:

The quality of voice during a call is measured using an index called RxQual which is measured on a scale of 0 to 7 for GSM networks where values closer to 0 indicate better voice quality and values closer to 7 indicate poorer voice quality. 5 is set as a benchmark value for voice quality and values between 0 to 5 are considered acceptable while values above 5 are considered unacceptable. The table given below shows the percentage of voice samples which had RxQual values less than 5 out of the total number of samples and the performance has varied from 95.13% (for Airtel) to 91.34% (for Aircel).

Operator name Total samples with RxQual between 0-5 Total number ofSamples % of samples with RxQual above threshold value Ranking
Aircel 583328 638650 91.34% 6
Idea 604464 641521 94.22% 2
Vodafone 609026 646986 94.13% 3
Airtel 620596 652342 95.13% 1
Reliance (GSM) 579130 631673 91.68% 5
Tata (GSM) 587595 625451 93.95% 4

Speech quality index:

Speech Quality Index (SQI) is a more sophisticated measure which is dedicated to reflecting the quality of the speech (as opposed to radio environment conditions). This means that when optimizing the  speech quality in network, SQI is the best criterion to use. The SQI is measured on a scale of 0 to 30 with values between 18 to 30 considered good and values less than 18 considered bad. The table given below shows the percentage of speech samples which had SQI values higher than 18 to the total number of samples and the performance varied from 88.86% (for Idea) to 82.33% (for Aircel).

Operator name Total Samples with SQI between 18-30 Total number of Samples % of samples with SQI above threshold value Ranking
Aircel 473836 575523 82.33% 6
Idea 527397 594826 88.66% 1
Vodafone 520130 594606 87.47% 2
Airtel 509210 591521 86.08% 3
Reliance (GSM) 437391 516892 84.62% 5
Tata (GSM) 488303 574697 84.97% 4

Carrier over interference:

the carrier over interference ratio (C/I) is the quotient between the average received modulated carrier power from the serving cell site and the average received co-channel interference power from undesired signal components, i.e. cross-talk, from other transmitters than the useful signal. C/I is measured on a scale of 0 to 30 with values between 15 to 30 considered good and values less than 15 considered bad. The table given below shows the percentage of samples which had C/I values higher than 15 to the total number of samples and the performance varied from 83.59% (for Airtel) to 77.39% (for Reliance GSM).

Operator name Total Samples with C/I between 15-30 Total number of Samples % of samples with C/I above threshold value Ranking
Aircel 319898 397912 80.39% 3
Idea 291720 356197 81.90% 2
Vodafone 166948 215218 77.57% 5
Airtel 215050 257270 83.59% 1
Reliance (GSM) 197660 255409 77.39% 6
Tata (GSM) 306533 381297 80.39% 4

The overall performance of Idea cellular 2G network is the best in Mumbai circle followed by Airtel, Vodafone, Tata Docomo, Aircel and Reliance in that order. Delhi circle drive test results coming soon, keep reading TelecomTalk for the latest updates in the Indian telecom industry.

Reported By

Leave a Reply

107 Comments on "Mumbai 2G Drive test results 2015- Idea has the best 2G network, Reliance not so reliable"

 

Sort by:   newest | oldest
vijay
July 31, 2016 10:18 am 10:18 AM

FAKE!!!! Idea had worst internet connection in mumbai, once you leave panvel its working fine! I’d already port-out my idea connection into airtel and airtel really working as faster as lightning!!!

Aniruddha
November 17, 2015 10:46 am 10:46 AM

Tata and Reliance cdma cannot be ignored as far as Mumbai circle is concerned.

UMESH Reliance
October 30, 2015 5:48 pm 5:48 PM

Now you all will get best GSM Coverage on Reliance. Reliance 3G @ Thunder Speed. Low Cost. Best Tariff. Better Network. Best Voice & DATA Services. Best 2G & 3G Services. Also on CDMA

wpDiscuz