DoT Not Acting on Non Payment of Dues Receives Backlash from Consumer Rights Foundation

DoT has decided to not take any coercive action on the telecom companies for missing the deadline of paying AGR dues

  • The Save Consumer Rights Foundation has filed a PIL in Supreme Court
  • The COAI has turned the PIL with mala fide interest and motivated
  • The telecom operators have to pay Rs 90,000 crore to the DoT

The telecom operators, Vodafone Idea and Bharti Airtel, missed the deadline given by the Supreme Court to pay the dues for the Adjusted Gross Revenue (AGR) issue on which it passed the verdict on October 24. The dues on each of these telecom operators were Rs 53,000 crore for Vodafone Idea and Rs 35,500 crore on Bharti Airtel. But, it seems that some of the organisations in India have not taken this as lightly and have termed the act of missing deadline for these operators as a deliberate attempt. As per an ET Telecom report, the Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI) which represents the major telecom companies, Reliance Jio, Bharti Airtel and Vodafone Idea has also lashed out on this Public Interest Litigation (PIL) which has been termed as “motivated” and “mala fide interest” petition against the telecom industry. The PIL is against the Department of Telecommunication’s (DoT) stance of not taking any action on the telecom operators after they did not pay the dues on time. To recall, the telecom operators have been given leeway by the DoT after they missed the deadline of making payment for the AGR on the account that the Supreme Court decision on the matter is pending over a petition.


DoT Holds Back on Coercive Action

The Department of Telecommunications (DoT) has decided not to take any coercive action against the telecom companies. It is worth noting that in a normal scenario, the Department of Telecommunication would have sent show-cause notices to these telecom companies asking them why they have defaulted on the payment. However, that has not been the case right now because of an internal notification inside the DoT, after the finance wing decided not to do something like this. But, on Saturday, the Save Consumer Rights Foundation filed a PIL in the Supreme Court, asking to strike down the decision of the DoT to not take any action against the telecom companies.

The consumer body said that the DoT could have encased bank guarantees which are in its possession and could have also cancelled the licenses of the telcos who had failed to pay their dues. Rajan Matthews, the Director-General of COAI, said, “The fact that it (the petition) does not have any reference to the other companies — besides operators — that are also included in this matter, appears to show mala fide interest to create problems, rather than solving it.”

COAI Speculates Mala Fide Intentions Behind PIL

Matthews also pointed out that even the non-telecom companies have to pay these AGR dues, but they have not been named in the petition. If the analysts are to be believed then if Vodafone Idea is made to pay its dues, then it will likely have to be shut down. The telecom company’s chairman also expressed similar sentiments saying that Vodafone Idea might have to shut shop if no relief comes its way. On the other hand, Bharti Airtel along with VIL are waiting for the result of a hearing on a modification petition which the telecom companies had filed seeking some relief from the Supreme Court.

To recall, on October 24, the SC had passed the verdict on the AGR matter in favour of the government thus declaring that the definition of AGR would include non-core items as well. This has led to a situation where the telecom industry is under the burden of Rs 1.47 lakh crore of dues which are to be paid to the DoT.

Arpit spends his day closely following the telecom and tech industry. A music connoisseur and a night owl, he also takes a deep interest in the Indian technology start-up scene and spends rest of his time spilling poetry and stories on paper.

Leave a Reply

Photo and Image Files
2 Comment threads
6 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
8 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted

is TT comments section dead now?? i dnt see any comments from the active users…

Rohit Jha

TT is getting more and more boring

Jio lover.. i can afford 6 paisa per minute..

Its due to high time lag in moderation

HC Venugopal

Fucking Govt need only money

Ranjana Das

what man ??? Government dues there so they want money, they run their businesses for almost many years without giving gov. fees and now suddenly they don’t have money !!! they all are robbers.
In fact it is good that government takes strict decision otherwise they don’t give a single penny infact they only fill their own pockets.


Sorry, Ranjana Das, I beg to differ. You have no idea about the pain an ISP has to take in order to cater the customer right. DOT charges 8% AGR, agreed, but what thereafter? There are so many franchisees, who buy local bandwidth and resell the same with their name, they don’t have even a proper license. They run their organisation, collect gst , and not remit the same, they only pay for bandwidth they’ve purchased. So these people save some where around 26% of the money on the total amount collected from the customer. These are mostly the local… Read more »


yes u r correct…they expand there 4g after jios launch…frm 2012 they sleeping…


So you are saying that these operators are providing / provided free services to People for almost 2 decades with out profit . They Invested , They Looted , now Bargaining with Supreme Court after diverting all funds investing in other countries / in other industry saying they have no money. Actually the ruling by SC on this matter is late. So they need to pay every thing without penalties and interests .

Recent Posts

iQOO 3 4G Variant to Cost Around Rs 35,000 and Less Than Rs 45,000 for 5G Model: Report

iQOO 3, which is all set to go official in India on February 25, will be available in both 4G...

Realme C3 Variant With Fingerprint Scanner and Triple Cameras Just Went Official

Realme C3 just went official in Thailand in a new avatar. Oppo spin-off Realme just launched its latest entry-level offering...

Bharti Airtel AGR Bill to Increase as DoT Might Add Videocon Dues

Bharti Airtel may face another setback as DoT is examining to add Videocon Telecommunications dues to the former’s AGR bill....