CARE Says 2G Verdict Has Many Negative Impacts, Indepth Analysis

By February 7th, 2012 AT 2:37 AM

With Supreme Court’s verdict regarding cancellation of 122 licenses for 2G mobile services given in 2008 Credit Analysis and Research Ltd has come forward with a in depth analysis on future implication.

Incumbents will be the beneficiaries

Supreme Court verdict has negative implications for telecom sector, lenders and overall business sentiments in country, shattering India’s image as an attractive investment destination.

The verdict will bring some cheers to incumbent players as it will lead to much needed rationalization in the overcrowded telecom sector as it will bring down the number of players per circle by a few.

At the same time, it might have some negative repercussions for the incumbents as Supreme Court has objections to the government.policy of ‘First-come-first-serve’ which was used for all 2G license allocation, in future the incumbent players might also be dragged into the controversy, as they were unaffected this time because they were not a party to the case.

Rating Implications: CARE Ratings

The following is the portfolio of the telecom service providers rated by CARE Ratings.

Service Provider

Outstanding Rating

No of circles where licence has been cancelled

Aircel (includes Aircel Ltd, Aircel Cellular Ltd and Dishnet Wireless Ltd)


[credit watch]

Idea Cellular Limited (ICL)


9 circles

Loop Mobile (India) Ltd


[credit watch]

Reliance Communications Ltd


[credit watch]

Sistema Shyam Teleservices Limited (SSTL)

CARE A1+ (SO)[backed by a 100% cash collateral to the extent of the PBG]/CARE A2 (SO)

[backed by a guarantee from Sistema JSFC]

21 circles

STel Private Limited (S Tel)


[credit watch]

6 circles

Tata Teleservices Limited (TTSL)


3 circles

Tata Teleservices (Maharashtra) Limited


CARE Ratings believes that the ratings of Idea Cellular Limited (ICL) and Tata Teleservices Limited (TTSL) will not be impacted by the cancellation of some of their licences as the impact on revenues of the circles related to the cancelled licences is not significant.

The ratings of Sistema Shyam Teleservices Limited (SSTL) are either backed by 100% cash collateral or by guarantee from the promoters and hence derive their strength from the structure and not from operations of SSTL in India.

Limited impact of tower companies

Some of the tower companies might be affected due to the verdict as they lose some of the new entrants as tenants, bringing down the already low occupancy rates.

Investments by impacted players to be delayed.

Substantial investment was planned by some of the affected players like Idea, Sistema Shyam and S. Tel, to roll out their networks, in the next 2-3 years, which might get delayed or cancelled.

As per Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) data, Idea, Sistema Shyam and S. Tel have planned investments of Rs. 12 billion, Rs. 275 billion and Rs. 20 billion for their network expansion and service roll out till 2014.

This in turn will impact the allied industries, including the telecom equipment providers and the passive infrastructure players.

Verdict is a negative for foreign investment in India

Most of the foreign players entered India as partners of local telecom firms after the license allotment. As in the last few years, India is already suffering from ‘policy paralysis’, the verdict will adversely impact the sentiments of foreign investors in India.


Out of the total 122 cancelled licenses, 39 license areas  were highly under-utilized as these five operators did not even have 1,000 subscribers in those circles as of December 2011, implying the services were not fully rolled out.The new entrants had unused spectrum, as we look at the number of subscribers from the cancelled license areas, it stands at 7.5% of total subscribers, whereas spectrum issued to these players stood at 31% and 21% of total spectrum allotted for GSM and CDMA respectively.

In other words, the impacted players had 7.1 MHz per million subscribers as compared to the overall number of 1.8 MHz per million subscribers. Based on this statistics, we assume that not all the players whose licenses were cancelled will participate in the auction, as it would require them to put more money for buying the license and spectrum at market rate.

This will reduce the number of players in almost every circle leading to some rationalization.

Drop a mail at news @ telecomtalk dot info

Leave a Reply

Photo and Image Files
30 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
20 Comment authors
ravi shekhardmWiMAXAPavisek Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
ravi shekhar

AP : @avisek BSNL has a hidden cost. Its losses are made good by the Government of India. So, people who are not subscribers of BSNL are also being made to pay for BSNL’s massive losses through taxes. There’s more. BSNL is chock full of incompetent, arrogant, lazy and corrupt staff. They continue to believe they are still in the pre-1990?s era of DoT’s absolute telecom monopoly. Besides, they have no performance targets to meet, no sales to drive. Even if BSNL makes massive losses, they are guaranteed to get their salaries every month without fail. This incompetence is exemplified… Read more »


Look at the total impact. Idea loses 13 licenses (6 will overlapping with the Spice buy).. it will rebid for 7 and potentially get refunded for those 6. Positive impact. Videocon – RIL rebid for these licenses? Etisalat DB – Will it exit and buy into RCOM? RCOM has already disconnected towers. Uninor – Major loser in this. Will have to shell more money. Will hope auction price is good. S Tel – Looking for exit with RCOM disconnecting towers? MTS – Will rebid for CDMA if auction price is reasonable. Unlikely to have too much of competition for CDMA… Read more »

Recent Posts

Bharti Airtel Offering Unique Benefits With Rs 249 and Rs 299 Prepaid Plans Compared to Rival Telcos

Bharti Airtel is trying to differentiate itself in the prepaid segment when compared to the competitors. In the process, the...

D2h and Dish TV Now Offering Double Benefit on Select Long Term Plans

The DTH operators had to discontinue their existing long term plans when the new Trai tariff regime came into effect....

Tata Sky Binge and D2h Magic Stick Compared For Features, Pricing and Content

The DTH industry is currently flooded with new digital products which try to bring the OTT content as close to...