Categories Technology News

Aadhaar Data Obtained Before 2016 is Illegal and Must Be Destroyed: Petition to Supreme Court

Published by
Chakri K

The Supreme Court today received information that outlined allegations against UIDAI saying that the data collection that went on from 2010 to 2016 by UIDAI was “illegal” and “invalid”. The arguments were presented in front of a five-judge constitution bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra and stated the invalidity of the information which was gathered in the years 2010-2016. Since, before Aadhaar scheme there wasn’t any stature which allowed UIDAI to gather data from the public.

Senior lawyer K V Vishwanathan, appearing for activist Aruna Roy, told the bench “The State’s failure

to enact the Aadhaar Act for six years meant that all enrolments done between 2010-2016 were without any informed consent”. The bench consisted of justices A K Sikri, A M Khanwilkar, D Y Chandrachud and Ashok Bhushan says a report by PTI.

The bench further went onto question the lawyer asking what should happen to the data which was collected before the Aadhaar scheme to play, to which Vishwanathan replied that the data should be destroyed as it had no legal foundation to be used by the concerned authority. The court had extended the deadline of March 31 further of mandatory linking of Aadhaar and declared it utmost necessary if the public wanted to avail government benefit and various services and schemes. The court did this in order to reach a conclusion to the ongoing argument regarding the Aadhaar number and its validity.

Lawyer Vishwanathan argued that Biometrics involve a person’s fingerprints and other personal data and a person has total control over his body which stands at the centre of a right to privacy. The lawyer further quoted “There was no informed consent or such other procedural guarantees and safeguards as are essential if the State seeks to infringe the right to privacy by taking biometric details of the citizens,” thus alleging the UIDAI of unlawfully obtaining private data from the public without any foundation and against statuary measures of that time.

He further added to his statements while speaking about the State and non-state actors “However, apart from the fact that the latter are defined by consent and choice, there is a qualitative difference between the Individual-State relationship, and the individual- corporation relationship, making privacy concerns vis-a-vis the former more salient.”

However, despite all this, the court couldn’t come to a conclusion, and the argument remains open in court for discussion. The court also asked other counsel for petitioners against the Aadhaar scheme, who would similarly question the validity of the data and also asked Attorney General KK Venugopal to begin his arguments on March 20.

Speaking for the West Bengal government Kapil Sibal, senior advocate also said that the citizen must have the choice to prove his identity and that it has to be linked with the status of the citizen to avail the benefits of the scheme.

This post was last modified on March 15, 2018 7:40 pm

Chakri K

Chakri is a go-to guy for your next smartphone recommendation. Back in his engineering days, he used to play with smartphones by installing custom ROMs and that passion got him into the tech industry. He still goes nuts about a smartphone knocking his door for review. Currently managing everything at Telecom Talk, Chakri is trying to master PUBG Mobile in his free time.

Share
Published by
Chakri K

Recent Posts

YouTube Testing Premium Lite Plan, Solving Key Content Issue for Lower Costs

It seems that Youtube, Google's video platform is testing its new Premium Lite subscription tier…

August 2, 2021 8:26 pm

Airtel Digital TV Gets Times Now Navbharat HD Channel In Hindi

Bharti Airtel’s DTH platform, Airtel Digital TV has been launching new offers for its new…

August 2, 2021 7:54 pm

OnePlus Nord 2 vs Oppo Reno6 vs iQOO 7, Which is the Best?

A series of smartphones have been launched in the Indian market. Among the lot, OnePlus,…

August 2, 2021 6:42 pm

Dizo Watch Could Be Your Budget Fitness Companion

Chinese Smartphone maker Realme recently launched its sub-brand Dizo, which had launched a couple of…

August 2, 2021 6:04 pm

Samsung Sets Up SEED Lab In Bangalore College for Research and Development

The Korean giant Samsung is not just known for its presence as one of the…

August 2, 2021 5:12 pm

TRAI Negates Plans of Bringing Floor Pricing Regime In Telecom Industry

One of the major impetus from the government on the regulatory front for the telecom…

August 2, 2021 4:18 pm