TRAI’s Independent Drive Test Results in Delhi and Hyderabad. Crowdsourcing could make things even Simpler

Earlier last week, Indian telecom regulator TRAI published the results of Independent Drive Tests conducted in Delhi and Hyderabad. TRAI had appointed M/s Phistream Consulting to conduct these tests.

mobile-india

The Methodology

  1. The tests were conducted in 2G + 3G Mode (Auto)
  2. The test results obtained from these drive tests were conducted to assess the network condition more specifically in terms of Radio Frequency (RF) Coverage; Rx Quality; Call Setup Success Rate; Call Drop Rate; Blocked Calls and Carrier to Interference ratio.
  3. In Delhi: The total drive route covered is approximately 600 km over a period of 4 days using two vehicles. The drive test was carried out between 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM from 3rd to 6th May 2016. ~12300 total calls were made for all 14 operators.
  4. In Hyderabad: Independent Drive test was conducted in Hyderabad & surrounding areas from 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM from 5th to 7th of May 2016. The drive test covered an area of approximately 300 km over a period of 3 days. A Total of ~7450 calls were made for eight 2G networks, four 3G networks and two CDMA networks covering 9 operatorsNote: On the 2nd day of the drive (6-May-16) due to 6 hours of rain, drive period was reduced by 1.5 – 2 hours.Roads and Areas covered in Hyderabad is shown in the below map.

Key Results

Delhi

  1. The Call Setup Success Rate (of > 95%) was met by all operators except MTNL 3G
  2. Except RCOM 2G, 3G, and MTNL 3G, all operators met the blocked call rate benchmark (< 3%)
  3. Most operators failed to meet Call Drop Rate benchmark (< 2%)
  4. Most operators failed to meet Rx quality benchmark (> 95%)

2G Network

Voice Dashbaord (2)

3G Network

Voice Dashbaord (3)

Hyderabad

  1. The Call Setup Success Rate (of > 95%) was met by all operators
  2. Except Aircel 3G all operators met the blocked call rate benchmark (< 3%)
  3. Most operators failed to meet Call Drop Rate benchmark (< 2%)
  4. Most operators failed to meet Rx quality benchmark (> 95%) except 3G networks of Aircel, Idea, BSNL, and 2G network of Vodafone

2G Network

Voice Dashbaord (1)

3G Network

Voice Dashbaord

For more detailed insights from the TRAI Reports check out TRAI IDT page.

Our Thoughts

While TRAI / partners are following an acceptable methodology to assess the call drop situation in major cities, it must be remembered that the call drop menace is experienced PAN India. Instead of trying to make progress with limited resources and time, TRAI must consider crowdsourcing route to check the ground reality.

Selection_001

Crowdsourcing

Crowdsourcing would mean inviting normal mobile phone users to report call drops. With smartphones being omnipresent, an app in the lines of TRAI’s DND app would make things easier for both TRAI and normal users. As we noted earlier, such an app for consumers

  1. Could be used to submit time and signal strength values at which a call got disconnected. In order to achieve this, the app can collect data at regular intervals in the background but submit only if a consumer wishes to submit a report.
  2. The app can also be used to make voluntary signal quality submissions.

In fact, telecom service providers can partner with TRAI for this initiative and make honest efforts to learn about call drop locations. Availability of reliable signal quality and call drop information would mean faster resolutions using analytical solutions at a telco’s end.

What do you think about TRAI’s Independent Drive Tests? Do you think they can solve the larger problem of call drops all over the country? Comment below or tweet to me @gischethans.

Reported By

Leave a Reply

21 Comments on "TRAI’s Independent Drive Test Results in Delhi and Hyderabad. Crowdsourcing could make things even Simpler"

 

Sort by:   newest | oldest
Munnu
June 13, 2016 1:54 pm 1:54 PM

With more than 70% of its 3G still on ‘H’ and 2G infrastructure of stone age era, BSNL has set benchmark for private player on how to give best service.
Time to give bonus to BSNL customer care staff from its 1,72,000 crore cash. LOL!

Sugu
June 13, 2016 10:23 pm 10:23 PM

BSNL’s ‘stone age’ H is still giving decent speeds, ~8Mbps in this test
I get min 2-3Mbps through out the day 🙂

[IMG]http://i64.tinypic.com/9rugxd.png[/IMG]
BSNL Kerala user here

Munnu
June 13, 2016 1:42 pm 1:42 PM

IDT results are highly skewed. It just gives pictures of A POINT OF TIME for particular place. Same results can’t be applied to persons indoor. This test shouldn’t be generalized as such.

Crowdsourcing seems good method in this case. TRAI can collect samples of all type(indoor, outdoor, moving) at any point of time(peak hour, night,) for given period(days, weeks, months) of time. It could give us more statistically significant reports.

sai charan kv
June 13, 2016 1:01 pm 1:01 PM

overall bsnl performance is very good when compared with airtel and aircel in all sectors.

Subha (KPA, Grater Kolkata)
June 13, 2016 5:54 pm 5:54 PM

Where from you are saicharan kv? If you really get good service from BSNL, then you are lucky… In our area especially in our city, every 4 day’s gap BSNL signal disappears. Interestingly signal becomes blank in every Firday night and comes back on Monday or Tuesday… sometimes it remains blank for a week… another thing till today after several complain and request, they were unable o give 3g service. Only ‘G’is present here… Shame on BSNL.

wpDiscuz