Should Mobile Operators directly compete with Banks? If yes, How?

Over the past few weeks several banks have announced their plans and some have already started charging for ATM transactions (both cash and non-cash) beyond a certain number of times. Naturally this has led to discontent amongst customers but there are lesser ways of escaping these charges unless one carefully plans ATM transactions. In this situation we explore a lesser used alternative, the Mobile Money offerings from mobile operators.

Mobile money offerings like Airtel Money, Vodafone’s M-Pesa though have been around for sometime now were never viewed as an alternative to bank accounts. Mobile money has been majorly showcased a solution to serve the unbanked populace, as a tool for financial inclusion and not as an alternative to banks and plastic money like credit / debit cards. For instance, Vodafone India’s 2014-15 H1 results cites that they have 80000 agents and over two million registered M-Pesa customers. M-Pesa was launched in India in April 2013. Vodafone’s numbers look very small when compared to over 72 million bank accounts that have been opened under Jan Dhan Yojana in a very short period of time.

On one side Vodafone is very vocal about unfriendly market in India and on the other side there lies under utilized potential. Of course raking in numbers like Jan Dhan Scheme would not be possible for mobile operators as they demand a different level of trust, but the present numbers are simply low and unimpressive. Airtel is also in similar situation with regard to Airtel Money.


How Telcos can set things right?

We believe telcos must look beyond just the financial inclusion part and start targeting the urban masses to grow the mobile money market. Cost conscious users (like me 🙂 ) are already exploring alternatives to reduce dependency on banks for daily expenses. This search would however be futile as stocking cash at home is not the answer to reduce dependency on banks.

This is exactly where telcos must be pushing mobile money.

  1. Target small merchants aka kirana store: Just offering mobile money to mobile users won’t suffice as there must be an ecosystem where one can pay for things with mobile wallet. This is where mobile operators must connect with merchants and follow a bank like approach. Even in bigger cities very few small scale merchants have POS machines from banks. Bringing the kirana store merchant under the mobile money ambit would certainly make things easier for both sellers and buyers. Sellers would see instant cash in their accounts and buyers need to not carry wallets and coins around – all one would need is just a mobile phone. Like banks’ POS terminals, telcos need not influence or gift mobile phones to merchants, many of them already have phones to carry out their business.
  2. Lower the cost barrier: While mobile operators need not spend a fortune like banks setting up ATM Kiosks and pay interest to customers for deposits, the charges are still on the higher side. A steep charge of Rs. 70 to transfer Rs. 5000 to a bank account is largely unjustified. NEFT / IMPS is much cheaper. Airtel Money charges – only Super account earns 4% interest16112014_16:45:05
  3. Provide incentives: Similar to reward points, cashbacks and discounts offered by banks, customers may be rewarded for mobile money usage. Instead of reward points, operators can go for simple thing like prepaid balance credit. This would play a significant role in promoting mobile money usage amongst students and non-earners like homemakers.
  4. Increase partner network: Operators need to ink more MoUs with e-commerce portals, government agencies etc.

Operators can easily do all of the above as they have everything at their disposal – robust sales network all over the country, marketing budget for TV and web etc.

How operators stand to Benefit?

Once mobile money becomes the de-facto standard for transaction values of at least below Rs. 5000 operators stand to reap benefits:

  1. Improved bottom line: Like voice and data, good amount of revenues would start coming from Mobile Money. This could mean 5-10% of revenue targets on conservative estimates.
  2. Improved Customer Loyalty as subscribers opting for MNP would have to transfer mobile money accounts as well. Hence MNP numbers would go down!
  3. VAS Revenues: A host of value added services can be designed and offered which can be paid for with mobile money

What do you feel about our observations on mobile money? Do you use mobile money for payments and how was your experience? Let us know through comments.

Reported By

Leave a Reply

10 Comments on "Should Mobile Operators directly compete with Banks? If yes, How?"


Sort by:   newest | oldest
November 18, 2014 4:36 pm 4:36 PM

Another awesome view and suggestion! Your way of thinking is really innovative!
Your idea can be used to connect the last mile of financially disconnected people. You could give this suggestion to PM’s fourm I think.

November 17, 2014 5:20 pm 5:20 PM
While direct competition is not possile between banks and Telecom operators, the point that you have raised is very valid. Operators can definitely change their outlook about Mobile money which is currently targeted at the unbanked population. Rather the focus can be to include the urban youth. But two main constraints that operators would face for this would be: 1) Cost in forming partnerships with the point-of-sales outlets which would further increase the cost of rolling out such offers 2) Due to presence of apps for various banks and other mobile banking options, adoption rates of the mobile money amongst… Read more »
Ganesh Srinivasan
November 17, 2014 8:34 am 8:34 AM
My view: Cash transactions at kirana stores will stay, and it’ll be uneconomical to install and operate gadgets at these places (similar story like ARPU in telecom parlance) Having left out numerous kirana stores, the next level is upmarket stores where every one is focused on – including credit and debit cards. There are few competing technologies, if you can call them so, and some of them stay as winners depending upon purely the economics Airtel money and the like have started with and have not moved beyond traditional bill pay, money transfer services. They have in a small way… Read more »