Offer Neutrality debate after Net neutrality? Airtel users discriminated by Paytm and Freecharge

Attractive offers in the form of cashbacks and discounts are one of the major perks of recharging prepaid numbers online. One of our readers, Yogesh brought a new discriminatory practice in the online recharge space to our notice.

trai-mobile

Prominent online recharge portals Paytm and Freecharge are now explicitly stating that their generous cashback offers are not applicable to Airtel users.

Airtel users, Sorry!

Paytm

11102015_10:48:10

Freecharge

11102015_11:19:44

Postpaid and DTH

Interestingly while Paytm has at least one offer for Airtel postpaid customers, Freecharge has nothing for Postpaid and even Airtel DTH users.

11102015_11:19:56 11102015_11:20:05

What could be the reason?

We approached Paytm and Freecharge for their comments through twitter on this new practice, but they haven’t responded yet to our queries. We believe there could be multiple reasons for this –

  1. A rigid commission structure from Airtel might leave less room for providers like Paytm to offer discounts or cashbacks
  2. Airtel might have asked these providers to refrain from offering benefits in order to drive customers to their own portal. This if successful would mean that Airtel need not pay commissions to third party portals. It may also be noted that Airtel also offers web-exclusive recharges.

Our Take

If this practice gains ground and is deemed successful, there is every likelihood that other telcos might take a similar approach to dissuade customers from heading over to third-party recharge portals. This in turn would mean lesser users and can thereby impact the bottom line of providers like Paytm and Freecharge.

Reported By

Leave a Reply

45 Comments on "Offer Neutrality debate after Net neutrality? Airtel users discriminated by Paytm and Freecharge"

 

Sort by:   newest | oldest
Prateek
May 28, 2016 7:12 pm 7:12 PM

I’ll just port my airtel SIM to Vodafone. Network and call rates of both r almost same and then I can get cashback offers. This is the advantage of portability, to all customers.

Ramesh Kumar
May 20, 2016 11:20 am 11:20 AM

I think Airtel App is not having a choice to enter coupon codes like as in paytm. Also there are no much benefits provided by Airtel to its customers like recharge cashback. I feel that airtel should keep in tie with Paytm. All airtel customers really support this.

Dipali
May 18, 2016 3:44 pm 3:44 PM

Airtel vale akele hi profit kamana chate hai…per wo ye bhul rahe hai ki dusro cooperate karne se unke customers badhenge…aur unhone ese akle sab profit kamane ka sochenge to unhe jald hi market se niklna padega…or loss hoga…

wpDiscuz